Book Review: Mr.Toyoaki Negishi’s "The Restructuring of Television Broadcasters"
When I launched the Convergence Institute in 2008, Toyoaki Negishi joined us on behalf of Nippon TV. He took a chance on what the broadcasting industry regarded at the time as a rather dangerous proposition. I owe him a great deal.
After the transition to digital terrestrial television and the push into online services, this veteran of the industry has now turned his attention to the restructuring of television broadcasters.
The book begins with the “new media” revolution of the 1980s, examining how cable and satellite television brought an explosion of channels and media outlets. I was working on those issues at the Ministry of Posts and Telecommunications at the time. They also marked the early stages of separating broadcasting infrastructure from content and services.
The next major challenge should have been convergence between broadcasting and telecommunications, including integration with the internet. But that is not how things played out.
Negishi recalls a remark made in 2006 by then-Minister for Internal Affairs and Communications Heizo Takenaka: “Why can’t we watch the internet on television?” The book also discusses the proposed Information and Communications Law, an initiative I originally put forward at the ministry. As the book explains, the idea was to deregulate the industry, including through the separation of infrastructure and content.
But after the proposed Livedoor–Fuji Sankei and Rakuten–TBS deals fell through, broadcasters became increasingly defensive. The book recounts initiatives such as NHK On Demand in 2008, Nippon TV’s Daini Nippon Television under “Director T” in 2010, and TVer in 2015. For the most part, though, broadcasters focused on protecting their ¥2 trillion television advertising market.
Meanwhile, online advertising grew from virtually nothing to more than ¥3 trillion, and video streaming became a ¥500 billion market. Broadcasters showed little appetite for capturing those new opportunities. Telecommunications and technology companies, including American players, moved in and took most of the business.
Next came the transition to digital terrestrial broadcasting, to which television stations devoted enormous effort. Negishi tells that story beautifully in another book, *The Tokyo Skytree Story Nobody Knows*, so I will leave it there.
http://ichiyanakamura.blogspot.com/2017/12/blog-post_25.html
The book then turns to the debate over broadcasting reform under the Abe administration around 2018. Proposals from the Prime Minister’s Office included abolishing Article 4 of the Broadcast Act and separating infrastructure from programming, supposedly to improve program standards and encourage new entrants.
For the first time in a decade, I was invited to present my views to the Regulatory Reform Council and broadcasting-related meetings at the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications.
My argument was simple: online content posed a much greater challenge in terms of standards; abolishing Article 4 would not bring in new broadcasters; separating infrastructure from content would not do so either—and, in any case, that separation was already possible. To create more entrants, you would have to allocate more spectrum. And if we had spectrum to spare, wouldn’t we be better off giving it to smartphones?
After a few rounds of explaining these basics, the debate quieted down. It was a reminder of just how political broadcasting is.
Which brings us to the book’s central subject: calls for industry restructuring have been gathering momentum since around 2021. Ideas on the table include combining broadcasting infrastructure, consolidating stations by region, and fostering cooperation between NHK and commercial broadcasters.
These proposals are consistent with the deregulatory direction of the Information and Communications Law. More than a decade after the legal framework was revised, the industry may finally be ready to put those ideas into practice.
In 2019, during parliamentary deliberations on amendments to the Broadcast Act that would allow NHK to stream its programs simultaneously online, I was asked to testify.
“Japan is more than a decade behind other countries in the convergence of telecommunications and broadcasting. The UK is moving toward an all-IP, all-cloud environment, sharing data and delivering services across multiple networks and devices. Japan hasn’t even begun.”
It has been five years since I made that impassioned plea. Perhaps the time has finally come.
There is something like the gentle sunlight of early autumn in this seasoned broadcaster’s vision of restructuring. Still, what the book describes is essentially a rearrangement of television *stations*—a reshuffling within the industry.
The landscape has changed completely since I established the Convergence Institute. Internet advertising now exceeds the combined advertising expenditure of the four traditional media—television, newspapers, magazines, and radio. Television has become a supporting player in the advertising market as a whole.
The imbalance in financial strength is striking: NTT could buy an entire major television network with a single year’s profit. Telecommunications, IT, and global technology giants such as GAFAM now operate in one interconnected digital marketplace. In other words, convergence has already happened.
Restructuring in this environment cannot simply mean second-tier players joining hands or selling themselves to one another. The relevant “industry” is no longer Japan’s domestic television business, but the global digital economy. Once-powerful broadcasters are now just one set of players among many. That is the new reality.
IP, cloud computing, data, AI, Web3, and the metaverse: in a technology-driven, global marketplace, which companies and investors will broadcasters work with to build their next businesses?
They will need management capabilities on par with those of other companies competing in digital markets.
I wish Japan’s television industry the very best.




